- Anice, Anprogapor, Apromar, Asaja, Aseprhu, Asoprovac, Avianza, Cesfac, COAG, Cooperativas Agro-alimentarias de España, Federovo, Intercun, UPA and Veteindustria have addressed Minister Luis Planas to show their concern about the new European regulations on Animal Welfare and have joined forces to demand that the Spanish Government take measures in this regard.
- These organizations declare that the European Regulation on the protection of animals during transport does not defend the European Model of Production, does not contemplate and is not based on the real problems of Animal Welfare in Spain and will have serious consequences for Spanish livestock production.
Madrid, April 10, 2024. The Spanish meat livestock sector is once again showing its concern about the new European regulations on Animal Welfare. Fourteen of the most prominent livestock, agri-food and veterinary organizations in our country (Anice, Anprogapor, Apromar, Asaja, Aseprhu, Asoprovac, Avianza, Cesfac, COAG, Cooperativas Agro-alimentarias de España, Federovo, Intercun, UPA and Veteindustria) have joined forces and sent a joint communiqué addressed directly to the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food, Luis Planas, so that Spain rejects the new European Regulation on the protection of animals during transport and related operations, amending Council Regulation (EC) No. 1255/97 and amending Council Regulation (EC) No. 1255/97.No. 1255/97 of the Council and repealing Council Regulation (EC) No. 1/2005.
These organizations insist that the new regulation does not have sufficient scientific basis and does not ensure an improvement in animal welfare during transport compared to the current situation. It is evident that the proposal has not been sufficiently worked on and that its social, economic and environmental impact has not been adequately estimated. They also argue that the solution must be to work to improve the implementation of the current legislative framework, the most demanding in the world, which would allow further increasing animal welfare.
The stringent measures of the new regulation would risk the economic sustainability of many rural areas in more disadvantaged and depopulated territories, reduce cultural diversity and benefit the interests of countries that occupy a privileged position for animal trade, while condemning peripheral countries (and island territories) to a serious competitive disadvantage, which would bear disproportionate costs.
"For all these reasons, we strongly request that Spain's position before the Council be to reject the proposal and demand its withdrawal, opposing it head-on, due to the serious damage it would cause to Spanish livestock production, to the value chain of food of animal origin, to citizens (whether producers or consumers), to the economy and rural development of our country, to its gastronomic culture and to the Spanish production model. The whole sector is united in the face of this incoherent proposal," the spokespersons of these organizations jointly state.
The serious consequences for Spain
Spain is one of the main producing countries in the EU and complying with this new regulation would imply a decrease in the productive capacity and competitiveness of livestock and food of animal origin production in our country.
These are the main reasons why this regulation is not viable:
1. It prevents fair and balanced trade among the member countries of the European Union. Due to the limitation of travel hours and temperatures allowed for transport, Spanish breeders would not be able to receive animals for breeding from countries where they are currently purchased, nor would they be able to export high-value genetics to the rest of the world.
2. Unprecedented administrative burden. The obligations included in the proposed standard entail a very high administrative, bureaucratic and personnel cost and many farms do not have the means to carry them out and the smallest will be the most affected.
3. The Spanish animal production sector suffers a clear discrimination due to its geographical situation and natural conditioning factors. In the proposed standard, the temperatures and geographical diversity of our country condition us and this proposal is a comparative disadvantage compared to other European regions given the average temperatures in Spain.
4. Night work. Difficulties in transporting animals during the day for long periods of the year will force workers in the livestock sector and related activities to work longer hours at night. This would imply higher costs for animal production, more occupational risks, greater difficulties in reconciling work and a greater risk to road safety, among others.
5. Decrease in exports. If this proposal progresses, Spain's export capacity would be severely reduced. The impact would not only affect livestock farmers, but also the food chain that depends on animal products (mainly the processing and cutting industries, but also the feed and input factories necessary for animal production and their processed products, and the transporters of animals and their products).
6. Inflation and decrease in State revenues If the text were approved, the consumer would pay the increases in the cost of production of the products of the basic basket. It would be more expensive to consume meat, eggs or fish, especially for people with lower incomes.